Security and Soccer in the City of Gold
South Africa has become a country used to exceeding expectations. When the ANC came to power in 1994 many South Africans expected violent reprisals, the 1994 genocide in Rwanda did nothing to allay these fears and South Africans flocked in numbers to the greener pastures of Australia, but the massacre never came, the reprisals never occurred, the white-owned property was never confiscated by the government.
Then in 1994, in the build up to the Rugby World Cup, there was general pessimism again, many thought the event would be a disaster, South Africa, isolated from the world for so long and with an aged infrastructure, would not be able to handle the hundreds of thousands of visitors, it was said, and the high crime rate would lead to the deaths of every tourist who entered the country.
There was a muted sense of surprise then, when the World Cup went off without incident and an even greater sense of shock, followed quickly by elation, when South Africa had the audacity to win the World Cup as well. It occurred right here in Johannesburg and was celebrated by a cynical turned sentimental Johannesburg news media as the moment the new South Africa was born. Those were the heady days of nation building and reconciliation, a time when some South Africans dared to believe we weren’t a country of failures after all.
That optimism did not last though.
A high crime rate, reported and rumored incidents of corruption in government, civil unrest over a lack of service delivery, embarrassing statements by politicians and, lately, a vulnerable economy, have driven South Africans to be more morose than usual about upcoming events of which we should be proud – for instance, the FIFA World Cup.
An indication of South Africa’s general pessimism can be found in the run up to the event. When SA first won the bid, the media immediately became suspicious that the country would not be able to handle the huge influx of people who would come to the country for the tournament. We didn’t have the infrastructure or the stadium capacity. So expansion of airports, roads, public transport and stadiums got underway and we said that it would never be finished in time. Now that everything has been finished and the country is set to welcome the international community, those of us with a tendency to pessimism have latched on to the fact that the visitor influx may be less than what was initially thought, so now we can call the World Cup a flop, a failure, an anticlimax. And it’s the government’s fault, because they misled us and exaggerated the figures.
Pessimism is part of the national character. This is more apparent than ever in discussions about the crime rate, with Johannesburg a benchmark of the problem nationally.
Joburg is without doubt the most dangerous city in South Africa, and South Africa is one of the most dangerous countries in the world. Many South Africans think that tourists are going to be slain in their hundreds and that those that do survive the gauntlet will leave with none of the worldly belongings with which they arrived. On a serious note, some have even gone so far as to suggest that any companies or government agencies promoting the country abroad are committing crimes against humanity because they’re encouraging tourists to come to a place in which they’ll be grievously harmed, or killed all together.
But how dangerous is the crime situation in real terms? South Africans are not usually inclined to drama, but when it comes to talking about the crime rate everyone becomes a drama-queen, making grand and sweeping statements such as that above. For a city like Johannesburg, what can we actually expect to see happening with regard to crime during the FIFA World Cup?
A survey conducted at O.R Tambo International Airport by the University of Stellenbosch’s Professors Sanette Ferreira and Ronnie Donaldson revealed that, of the 907 foreign tourists interviewed, 6% or 54 people became victims of some form of crime. This is just slightly higher the number of South Africans who are the victims of some form of crime each year (2.6 million out of a population of roughly 49 million). It is still an unacceptably high figure, but it hardly constitutes the media and public hysteria that so often accompanies narratives on the crime rate.
Tourists are generally more vulnerable because they do not know Johannesburg the way locals do, and because they’re on holiday there is a subconscious tendency to trust strangers, which can be dangerous in the wrong areas of the city. But South Africa’s, and indeed Johannesburg’s, crime situation has been publicized extensively enough that there can be no tourist who is unaware of the crime rate, and it is their responsibility to find out where the problem areas are. Generally speaking, they’re in the low-income parts of the city. The whole of Johannesburg is not a cesspit of crime and should not be considered as such.
It is also worth considering that crime in South Africa is an issue that has been taken into account by government in the build up to the World Cup, 44,000 police officers have been specifically trained to provide security during the event, $90 million worth of equipment has been purchased – everything from cars, boats and helicopters to bullet-proof vests, radios and guns.
The cynical among us will of course point out that $90 million could have been better spent on schools and hospitals, while still claiming that crime will be the downfall of the World Cup.
In every way the country is prepared, and so is Johannesburg, its undisputed powerhouse. This is the city through which most tourists will enter the country, and because of Constitution Hill, Soweto, the Apartheid Museum and other landmarks, as well as the new Soccer City Stadium, the city will be explored and enjoyed by a large number of those visitors.
Will they be victims of crime? Some of them unfortunately will be, mobile phones will be stolen, handbags might be swiped, some may be mugged, some, horrifically, may even be raped or killed. That is the reality, but the chances are not as great as one might imagine. They are very low, the vast majority of crime committed is theft.
This will undoubtedly embarrass the country, for every incidence of crime will be widely reported on during the World Cup, but encouragingly, most tourists who were victims of crime were planning on returning to South Africa and said they would recommend coming here (according to the University of Stellenbosch’s survey).
Another finding of the survey is also interesting, 51% of respondents had never been to South Africa before, and of that 51%, the vast majority had a more favorable opinion of SA upon leaving than the perception they’d had before they arrived.
Comments
More Johannesburg News
RSS-
Rose says US Open win only possible after healing of traumatic early career scars
South African golfer Justin Rose has admitted that his US Open triumph was only possible after the healing of the scars from his 'traumatic' early career. Although the new world No.3 has been tipped for greatness ever since making his name as a teenage amateur at The Open in 1998, however, that period was followed by a depressing 21 successive missed cuts as a fledgling professional, the Mirror ...
-
Mandelas condition continues to improve but remains serious
Anti-apartheid icon Nelson Mandela's condition "continues to improve but his condition remains serious," President Jacob Zuma said on Thursday. Zuma was speaking after visiting Mandela who has been hospitalized for a recurring lung infection since Saturday. Zuma, accompanied by African National Congress (ANC) Treasurer- General Zweli Mkhize, visited Mandela in hospital in ...
-
Scot and South African appointed to spearhead Commonwealth sport development projects
This position will lead the sponsorship new business acquisition process for the NBA for Africa. The focus will be on new partner development - prospecting, pitching, negotiating and securing new corporate ...
-
Julien Benneteau upends Kevin Anderson in early Eastbourne match
Kevin Anderson in first-round play. The 32nd-ranked Benneteau, who made the finals at the Rotterdam event this year, prevailed over hard-serving South African Anderson 7-6 (7-4), 6-2 at Devonshire Park. Australian Bernard Tomic rebounded from a recent dry spell with a 6-3, 6-4 decision over British wild card James Ward, while Czech ...
-
AB de Villiers says South Africa will be Trophy champions or chokers
AB de Villiers has it in his power to keep South African tears at bay at The Oval on Wednesday - unlike the last time his country met England in a global semi-final.In March 1992 an eight-year-old De Villiers could only watch television in Pretoria as his heroes got the rawest of deals in Sydney. South Africa returned following a 12-minute rain interruption to discover, having needed 22 runs ...
-
Motshekga Re-draft will take 6 months
Angie Motshekga said on Tuesday. Last week, the Equal Education (EE) group said it was taking her to court for allegedly breaching an agreement to publish the document by 15 May. The matter was to be heard in the Bhisho High Court on 11 July. On Tuesday, Motshekga said she has been communicating with EE to update it on progress with the norms and standards. She wrote it a letter on 9 May in ...
-
Enough is enough - Mthethwa
Nathi Mthethwa was saddened by the death of Major General Tirhani Maswanganyi, whose body was found early on Tuesday morning, his office said. "We are saddened by this tragic loss of a senior cop who dedicated his life to serve the vulnerable and the weak in society," Mthethwa said in a statement. "The SA Police Service [SAPS] is poorer, the Gauteng provincial team is ...
-
Ramphele worried over IEC
Mamphela Ramphele said on Tuesday. "The Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) has eroded as an independent electoral commission," she told the Cape Town Press Club. She said Agang SA was in talks with other political parties, the Democratic Alliance in particular, to double-check certain IEC processes. "[We need] to be reassured that first of all, we are not going to have party ...
-
SAHRC welcomes Cape jogger ruling
Nathi Mthethwa for a review of findings in a matter involving a Cape Town jogger was welcomed on Tuesday. "We are very pleased with [the judge's] finding that the minister must respect the [SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC)] and the work done by the commission," its chairperson Lawrence Mushwana said in a statement. "This should really send the message to other ...
-
Premier condemns cop killing
Johannesburg - The death of Major General Tirhani Maswanganyi is a senseless blow to Gauteng's war against crime, Premier Nomvula Mokonyane said on Tuesday. "In the memory of Major General Maswanganyi all of us law-abiding citizens should take up the cudgels and say: 'We will not be cowed into submission by criminals. We will honour Maswanganyi by making sure that the ...
-
Nkaneng looting a Marikana issue
Pretoria - Police plans to protect the Nkaneng informal settlement against armed protesters in Marikana last year were at issue before the Farlam Commission of Inquiry on Tuesday. While North West deputy police commissioner General William Mpembe said the police's plan had included the protection of the whole area, the commission's evidence leader Mbuyiseli Madlanga submitted that: ...
-
Immigration officer wanted R7 000 bribe
Johannesburg - An immigration officer appeared in the Polokwane Magistrate's Court on Tuesday on a charge of corruption, the Hawks said. "He was granted bail of R1 000 and the case was postponed to 25 July for final investigations," said police spokesperson Paul Ramaloko. Edmond Lekgothoane, 37, was arrested on Friday for allegedly soliciting a R7 000 bribe from a ...
-
Limpopo initiation schools probed
Johannesburg - Claims of initiation schools operating illegally in Limpopo are being investigated, the traditional affairs department said on Tuesday. The probe was being conducted by a team from the provincial house of traditional leaders, the department said in a statement. The bogus schools were apparently in the Capricorn, Waterberg, Sekhukhune and Mopani districts. Limpopo's 142 ...
-
Is Nelson Mandela too soft on white South Africans Robert Mugabe says so.
In a new documentary, the Zimbabwean president says that Mandela 'was too much of a saint' and takes the famous South African to task for not doing enough for the black ...
-
South Africa want to reverse the ball to swing it like England
AB de Villiers is prepared to give England the benefit of the doubt over accusations that the Champions Trophy hosts have been guilty of ball-tampering. Ashley Giles, ...
-
Pupil takes Motshekga to court
Angie Motshekga to the Bhisho High Court on Tuesday over conditions at her school, Equal Education (EE) said. Moshesh Senior Secondary School pupil Palesa Manyokole wanted the court to act against those responsible for standards at her school, EE said. The school is in Queen's Mercy, a rural village near Matatiele. "Learners from the school first wrote to Equal Education in 2012 to ask ...
-
England v South Africa the key clashes
Amla had the Indian sign over the English last year, carrying his eye-catching form from a successful three-Test series (482 runs at an average of 120.50) into the drawn one-day contest that followed (335 at 111.66). There was a career-best 150 rattled up at the Rose Bowl, and an unbeaten 97 accumulated at Trent Bridge, with the opener irresistible and the home side rendered blunt. Anderson, ...
-
ANC withdraws Mazibuko weight remark
Lindiwe Mazibuko 's weight, and apologised to her on Tuesday. He did so after Deputy Speaker Nomaindia Mfeketo ruled emphatically that the comment was unparliamentary. "In the past, many rulings were made on remarks regarding members' physical appearance, and these have always been found to be insensitive, offensive and a violation of a member's dignity," she ...
-
Sapu wants justice for top cop killing
Johannesburg - The SA Policing Union (Sapu) expressed sadness over the murder of Major General Tirhani Simon Maswanganyi, whose body was found on Tuesday morning. "We fall short of words to express this great loss as he is one of the top 20 generals around this province," General Secretary Oscar Skommere said in a statement. "Sapu has worked well with Major General ...
-
Ramphele Scars of racism havent healed
Mamphela Ramphele said on Tuesday. "The Democratic Alliance and I disagreed, not because they have a different policy frameworkbut [because] they don't understand just that," she told the Cape Town Press Club. "[It is] this issue that it doesn't matter how hard we try. The scars of racism in this country have not completely healed." She believed it was necessary ...
-
PAC rejects Paycos Mandela statement
Johannesburg - The PAC distanced itself from a statement by Pan Africanist Youth Congress (Payco) spokesperson Sello Tladi calling former ...
-
Ex-SA ambassador criticises Israel
Israel & the Palestinian Territories This up-to-date guide to Israel and the Palestinian territories includes a history chapter by Was R245.95 Now ...
Johannesburg Focus
-
Security and Soccer in the City of Gold
In 1991, on the 11th of February, South Africa celebrated an immense moment of change as Nelson Mandela walked free from prison, then on the 25th of June 1995, the Springboks defeated the All Blacks and South Africa became the winners of the rugby world cup. These two events were indicative of the country’s potential, especially when set against the pessimism of the public and the global community at large.
South Africa has become a country used to exceeding expectations. When the ANC came to power in 1994 many South Africans expected violent reprisals, the 1994 genocide in Rwanda did nothing to allay these fears and South Africans flocked in numbers to the greener pastures of Australia, but the massacre never came, the reprisals never occurred, the white-owned property was never confiscated by the government. Read more
News from around our Network
